Australian Mining Companies Chose Battery-Electric Over Hydrogen Fuel Cell Mining Trucks

Mining corporations like BHP, Rio Tinto, and Fortescue don’t care a fig about zero-to-sixty instances, huge touchscreens, or vegan leather-based interiors. Their concern — their solely concern — is for the underside line. Because the inexperienced revolution strikes ahead, they’re in search of methods to decrease the carbon emissions related to their mining actions, and which means shifting away from diesel engines. What are the alternate options for large mining vans that may weigh a whole lot of tons? There are two — batteries or hydrogen gas cells.

Each present the electrical energy wanted to show electrical motors, so which is healthier? The businesses have executed their analysis, gathered the information, and created the spreadsheets. For them, the reply is evident. Battery-powered mining vans are the way in which to go. Why? Effectivity. BHP has now joined Rio Tinto and Fortescue in preferring electrical mining vans over hydrogen gas cell vans as a result of they’re extra environment friendly. Not just a little bit extra environment friendly, a lot extra environment friendly.

“Annually, our Australian operations use roughly 1,500 [million] liters of diesel in over 1,000 items of kit. Over half of that is utilized in our truck fleets. Electrification is the popular pathway to get rid of this diesel,” mentioned Anna Wiley, BHP’s vp for Australian planning and technical capabilities.

“Utilizing hydrogen for instance, we see the best losses at [the fuel-to-tank stage] attributable to technology, storage and transportation in comparison with minimal losses in electrical energy technology and transmission. As soon as on board, the gas must be transferred to power. In each at this time’s diesel-electric know-how, and in a hydrogen system, the gas is used to generate electrical energy to drive the electrical wheel motors which has further losses in comparison with direct feed,” she instructed Hydrogen Insight just lately.

Electrical vans display an total effectivity of round 80%, whereas hydrogen and diesel vans present solely about 30% and 20% effectivity, respectively. These figures contemplate the entire fuel-to-wheel power effectivity losses, making the electricity-to-battery-to-electricity course of extra environment friendly than the electricity-to-hydrogen-to-electricity cycle, based on Vitality Improvements.

Price financial savings for electrical mining vans are additionally increased than initially estimated. Comparisons targeted on the hydrogen gas that’s already created, ignoring the losses concerned in hydrogen manufacturing. Vitality knowledgeable Saul Griffith factors out that even with an ideal machine, solely just a little over 70% of the power generated from photo voltaic cells might be transformed into hydrogen. Which means virtually 80% of the unique renewable power generated for the hydrogen system can be misplaced by the point the truck’s wheels had been shifting. In distinction, electrical vans require much less wind and photo voltaic power to cowl the identical distance and provide extra price financial savings.

Battery-Electrical Mining Vehicles

The desire for electrical autos by BHP, Rio Tinto, and Fortescue doesn’t imply the EV revolution in heavy tools is full, nonetheless. For one factor, the provision of battery-powered ultra-heavy vans is a matter. Producers are within the early phases of getting such autos into manufacturing.

Issues are shifting ahead within the heavy truck trade, nonetheless. As CleanTechnica reported earlier this year, Nouveau Monde Graphite and Caterpillar have signed definitive agreements to supply a zero emission fleet of electrical mining vans to assist operations at NMG’s Matawinie Mine. Volvo can be offering battery-electric mining equipment to Boliden, a Swedish mining firm for its fleet of underground mining tools.

As well as, the businesses might want to develop their electrical car infrastructure to assist a rise in the usage of battery-powered equipment. BHP has already contracted for 1.2 GW of renewable power, however might have as much as 4 instances that quantity to fulfill its future electrical wants because it provides battery-electric tools.

“There can be some downsides to offset this comparable effectivity benefit from electrification, reminiscent of how we resolve long run storage and constraints to mining operations attributable to energy infrastructure,” Wiley mentioned. “Nevertheless, our view is that an electrified mining fleet is extra financial and extra achievable than the choice gas sources.”

Hydrogen Has A Position In Mining

BHP is growing what could turn out to be the world’s largest potash mine in Saskatchewan, Canada, and plans for 80% of the underground mining autos at that facility to be battery-electric. Nevertheless, it’s inspecting the potential for utilizing hydrogen to exchange fossil gasoline within the processing of the uncooked supplies it extracts. Since fossil gasoline would account for 40% of the carbon emissions from the Jansen facility, substituting hydrogen would reduce total emissions significantly.

The choice by Australia’s three largest mining corporations to give attention to battery-electric mining vans is according to the current expertise in The Netherlands, the place a current subsidy spherical acquired no functions for hydrogen vans. The Dutch authorities’s ongoing funding in hydrogen refueling stations has been questioned by environmental teams, which argue that electrical vans are extra power environment friendly and will turn out to be the norm by 2035. Unbiased analysis helps this conclusion, and means that electrical vans will probably be cheaper than both diesel or hydrogen alternate options. As of February 2023, there have been 27 hydrogen vans and over 400 electrical vans within the Netherlands, Vitality Improvements experiences.

Australia & Hydrogen

The nascent inexperienced hydrogen trade in Australia had hopes that the large mining corporations can be a buyer for his or her merchandise, however the determination by BHP, Rio Tinto, and Fortescue is a blow to these plans. The truth is, the hype about hydrogen in Australia is starting to fade. Based on my colleague, Michael Barnard, Fortescue was one of many prime proponents of mining tools powered by hydrogen gas cells till it ran the numbers and noticed that hydrogen simply doesn’t pencil out, irrespective of how passionate its advocates could also be, even when one among them is Andrew Forrest, the top of Fortescue Mining Group.

Michael Barnard says the tipping level got here on the Vitality and Mines Australia Summit in Perth on June 14, the place Christiaan Heyning, the top of decarbonization for Fortescue Mining Group, mentioned the corporate was selecting electrical quite than gas cell vans as a result of utilizing hydrogen would require thrice the quantity of electrical energy. He was joined by John Mulcahy, principal adviser on floor mining and know-how at Rio Tinto, Australia’s largest iron ore mining firm.  “The hydrogen cycle is about one third as environment friendly, so our preliminary view is let’s drive it with batteries due to the upper effectivity, the lesser affect on infrastructure and distribution programs,” he instructed the convention.

Effectivity is the watchword for the inexperienced financial system. The effectivity of inner combustion engines is terrible. Because the world continues to warmth up, can we afford to waste practically three-quarters of the power contained in a gallon of gasoline or diesel gas? Can we afford to make use of hydrogen autos which can be 30% environment friendly when electrical autos are 80% environment friendly? Being environmentally aware means not being profligate with the power we do use. On this planet of vehicles and vans — any vehicles and vans — battery-electric is solely the neatest and most cost-effective technique to go.

I do not like paywalls. You do not like paywalls. Who likes paywalls? Right here at CleanTechnica, we applied a restricted paywall for some time, nevertheless it all the time felt improper — and it was all the time powerful to resolve what we must always put behind there. In concept, your most unique and finest content material goes behind a paywall. However then fewer folks learn it! We simply don’t love paywalls, and so we have determined to ditch ours.

Sadly, the media enterprise continues to be a troublesome, cut-throat enterprise with tiny margins. It is a unending Olympic problem to remain above water and even maybe — gasp — develop. So …